Showing posts with label think. Show all posts
Showing posts with label think. Show all posts

Wednesday, November 11, 2015

Dark Chocolate


It was going to be the mundane experience of checking out groceries for the week at a store I’ve been going to for years. It generally starts with a perfunctory nod and mumbled greetings by a person at the counter. Then, as I place the milk and bread on the belt, my eyes would be caught by the cover of tabloids that talk about cheating celebrities and their impending divorces. Then, my mind would jump to the internal workings of places that come up with these stories. I’d imagine the brainstorming sessions at these places and the personal lives of people that work at these places. Do they keep a stash of awkward pictures of each celebrity? I’d wonder. By that time typically I’m asked to swipe my card and express my preferences about the milk container going directly into the cart. All this ends with another nod and exchange of good wishes with the stranger before she moves on to the next customer.

It started off the same this time and would have ended as usual if the packet of dark chocolate had not jumped into the bag as it did. “Wow! Boop – it jumped in there as if it knew that’s where it was supposed to go”, she said. She was elderly but energetic and wore her hair in a manner that seemed to suggest that she did not belong in there. “That’s one funny piece of chocolate. Boop – it jumped in there” she said again. “Somebody could write a story about it. It could become big. Like Harry Potter. She made a billion dollars with that.”, she said. This was not the human robot I was used to seeing. “Do you write?”, I asked. “Yes, I do”, she said. “Stories?”. “Poems and songs. My poems were published in the millennium book of poems. I was one of the selected 100 poets.”

Do we have no use for a poet other than to scan items off a conveyor belt?

Why is our society rewarding me, an engineer, but not her, an artist? She is arguably a better artist than I’m an engineer. I would not make it to the list of 100 selected engineers of my time. The answer, unflattering for me, is not that I’m good or talented but that I’m useful. The world happens to need my skill at this point in time. Born in a different time in history, I’d likely have been laying bricks for her house or fixing the wheel of her carriage. Maybe somewhere in the future that we engineers are building today lies a much different kind of society. One where machines autonomously produce our food, build our houses and keep us healthy. What does one do in such a world? History suggests that we’d continue to toil feverishly in that world too. With all the mundane problems behind us, hopefully, we’d be consumed by creative pursuits. We’d stretch our minds unfettered by physical limitations. Unencumbered by the trivialities that go by the name of  making a living. Hopefully, the ones that are rewarded in that world are the ones that see a piece of chocolate slip into a bag and see a story in it. And are unafraid to share it.

Saturday, August 27, 2011

84 kilo bytes of entropy

I obviously was conscious of the fact that I hadn't written anything for a while. But I was shocked to realize that the last one was posted more than 2 years back. I must admit, it was not due to lack of trying. No, it wasn't a blogger's block.

One of the reasons, as I vaguely remember was my idea to pause for a while, take time to read, absorb ideas and process them before I wrote anything. A bigger one though was probably my confusion about the whole purpose of writing. Having given the blog a grandiose title of Making Sense Of It All and having found that it was easier said than done, the very format of a single page with multiple articles, each of which was expected to do its bit for standing up to the challenge of the title was a bit intimidating.

So, I decided to reformat the blog to make allowance for the fact that it is only very rarely that I'm making sense of anything. Most of the time, it is a reflection of jumbled competing ideas in my head trying to grasp this intricate world - sometimes oversimplifying it and sometimes just missing the point.

Like a good engineer, I wanted to backup the blog before I messed with the design template. My first shock was to see that I only had 22 posts in all. A bigger one was when I copied all the pages and zipped them up. The zip file was only 84 kilo bytes long. And I'd guess that most of it was just the html markup.

Less than 84 kilo bytes of entropy? That doesn't sound like a lot. But how does one make sense of this number? I just did some calculations - that's less than 4 bits of information for every hour that I've lived. Is that a fair comparison though? If you zipped up all of JK Rowling's works, or Shakespeare's works or Feynman's papers, how big is it going to be? How many bytes would it take to write down the theory of everything?

How many bytes of entropy would it take... to make sense of it all?


Thursday, April 16, 2009

Overheard in my head


A: I'm thinking of the tip that authors of self help books go around giving people.
B: Which one?
A: When faced with a problem, ask yourself what someone else would do. Someone you admire and think is successful.
B: I always thought that was demeaning. It is as if you'd rather trust someone else's judgment than your own. Like the best you can do is to borrow another person's wisdom.
A: Yeah. I know. But that would be true if you were to actually walk up to the other person and ask for help. This is completely different. Don’t you see?
B: In the first case, you talk to the real person and in the second you seek the help of that person's model in your head. Sounds equally pathetic to me.
A: Think about it. You are consulting the other person's model in your head. Not the person. So, who is the one doing the thinking? You are running his software but its running on your machine. Makes sense?
B: Well, you are running his ready-made software. You have no idea how he made it. That's still no good.
A: Don’t push the analogy too far now. Forget the software example. You can run a program without knowing how it was written. But that's not true here. If you are consulting this person - I mean his phantom in your head - about a problem that you never saw the real person solve, and his phantom in your head produces a solution, isn't it you that really came up with it?
B: But then again, it is his algorithm that you are using to come up with the solution. It is not really yours. You blindly run your problem through his algorithm.
A: Now, that's a better analogy. And I agree with you. To run his algorithm in your head, you need to know his algorithm. And you wouldn’t be running it on your problem if you weren't convinced that it was right. So basically, you are using something that you understand well and something that you know to be a good general solution to the problem. Who cares if the algorithm was borrowed?
B: The point remains that it isn’t your solution. In fact, it's worse than that. You are probably convinced that his algorithm is right not because you can see why it works but because you think this person is successful and he cannot be so if his algorithms didn’t work. So basically, you are running an emulation of something you don’t understand because you have empirical evidence of its quality.
A: That's a hard one to refute. I'm probably oversimplifying this and that's why I'm losing. Let me start afresh. We know that we don't quite think algorithmically. And even if we do, having a clear understanding of someone else's algorithm - clear enough to emulate it - sounds impossible. Atleast extremely difficult. More often, we are guessing their algorithm. Based on our own understanding of everything. So unless we are actually emulating what the other person verbally claims to be doing, your knowledge of the other person's algorithm is nothing but your best explanation for how he does what ever he does. In fact it is your algorithm to produce his results. It is probably nothing like his algorithm. And probably is even way better than his.
B: If it's your algorithm, I wonder what the other person's contribution was at all. All he did was to assert that something was possible? Is that all we need?
A: It seems so. And that's not the end. We consult not one but multiple experts on different problems. Like a swiss army knife, we just pick whoever is best suited to the problem.
B: A swiss army knife of our models of peoples' wisdom. Strange but plausible. To go with it, probably there is a little bit of our original self that does the picking and choosing.
A: What is this swiss army knife but our own self? And isn't it as original as anything? Isn't each one of those phantom people nothing but our own doing? And do all of them have to be phantoms of real people? Can't you have a phantom of sherlock holmes? That would be a phantom of a phantom born in someone else's mind. An army knife of phantoms of real and phantom people. Sounds hardly like me.
B: A chimera of sorts. Interesting.

Wednesday, March 11, 2009

I'm told that scientists have an explanation for why smells are so good at bringing a slice of the past alive. It is hard to not be carried to a different time and space by some smells you didn't even know existed. So it is, for me, with songs. It is probably because I have the habit of playing something endlessly if I like it. And I have been lucky enough to have done that over very long periods of time.

Long lone walks on the snow in Buffalo with a small playlist of favorites. Long hours at work with just one song playing all day. Very long lonely rides on a minivan everyday through traffic with the same songs playing on the radio… the list is endless….

The right smells are rare to come by. That probably adds to the magic. Songs, on the other hand, can be played anytime. I can call upon any one of them from my collection of portals to the past. But there's a problem here -these portals - they cannot be made to order instantly. They, like Andy Dufresne's rocks, need a lot of time and pressure. That's not the only problem though. Every time you play the song, every time you take the portal, you lose a bit of it. The next time, it doesn't exactly take you where it used to. It's as if someone slightly moved the telescope when you weren't watching. And when that happens enough number of times, it just stops being a portal. It is no longer a wormhole. Just a regular song like the rest.

So I try not to take the portals very often. I don’t want to disturb the orientation of my telescopes. I want all of them pointing at the right stars. Probably if I looked through them just rarely enough, they'll remain rightly oriented. Probably they'll bring up the same memories every . And more than anything, I hope that, as I try hard not lose any of the portals to the past, more are being forged for me to travel back to today… some day when nothing will be as it is now.

Monday, July 14, 2008

Blur it all

I have a wish.

I want a movie to be made. A very special one. One that tells a story that spans thousands of years. One in which a year lasts only a second. It shouldn’t just span all the way along the timeline. It should conquer complexity and win over the detail devil. People and places should not be that but stand for populations and worlds. When a person speaks in the movie, it should be much more. It should be the voice of all of humankind. When he laughs, it should, undeniably, be only to reflect the sheer joy of existence. Nothing less. Nothing trivial. Nothing. But a celebration of life. Just that. He would age in the movie, of course. Like the humankind has. Would start off innocent. Lose it quickly. Then get wiser. Later senile.
Certainly, there would be more than one actor. If each one would be everyone, I wonder how that would work. Probably each actor should not be everyone. Probably each one should speak for all men of one kind. But there shouldn’t be many. We don’t want the details. We don’t want to see individuals. No aberrations. No mavericks. We don’t want to see the parts. Just the whole.
And the plot. Well. That would be something. The mother of all scripts. A punch would be a skirmish. A scuffle, a battle. And a murder, a nuclear war. A stroll would be a voyage across the seas. An adventure would be landing foot on a rock in the sky. A mad man would be a nation gone berserk. A population hypnotized.

Details are good. They distract us.

Saturday, December 22, 2007

Reponse to comments

This is a response to the comments that I have received for my articles (“God of small things”[1] and “Down the rabbit hole” [2] ) and arguments/discussions that I have had with friends (GH, TTV, AS, AB, EP, BV, SB, DJ, RG, OM and others).

This is what I hear often:

  1. You cannot disprove the existence of anything supernatural.
  2. So the scientifically correct position is to say that you are agnostic.
  3. Since you call yourself an atheist, you are being irrational.


And to make sure that we are talking about the same thing, I looked up the oxford dictionary.

Agnostic: noun a person who believes that nothing can be known concerning the existence of God.

Atheism: noun the belief that God does not exist.

I was interested in knowing whether an agnostic friend of mine believed in God. (I must admit, I still have no idea). His reply was “No.” But ofcourse, he added “I donot NOT believe in God either.”

Bear with me while I digress a bit…

We have a lot wonderful mental phenomena: Dreams, feelings, emotions, ideas, feeling-of-oneness-with-the-universe… you name it. We (humans) have always been wonderstruck by these and have sought explanations. We started off imagining a “mind” that did all the thinking and somehow communicated with the body. That did not explain much but atleast we got started. And then as we started cutting open people and studying what they were made of, we started making sense of a lot of things. Physical phenomena were no longer mysterious. They were still wonderful but no longer mysterious. The same started happening with the mental phenomena. We injected radioactive substances into the bloodstream and studied the flow of blood in people’s brains during different mental activities. We slowly started mapping the brain and realizing that most of what we had attributed to the “mind” was a result of what was happening in the brain. We did not just assume that. We made hypotheses to explain observations and data obtained by studying activity in the brain objectively. We derived predictions from these hypotheses and eliminated hypotheses which did not make correct predictions. We kept the ones that did and improved upon them as we started learning more about the brain. And throughout this process, the role of the non-physical non-detectable mind (which was postulated for want of a better explanation) kept diminishing. Now we stand at a point where only super-mysteries like consciousness are attributed to the “mind”. And since we know that we have only scratched the surface with our studies of the brain, we know that the brain has potential to explain all that and more. In fact the philosophers and the neurobiologists are doing a wonderful job in providing convincing explanations to these “mysteries”.

Ask me if I “believe in the existence of a non-physical mind” and my answer would be “No”. And that is not because science has “disproved the existence of a non-physical mind” but since we have “explained- away” the non-physical mind. Wait. We haven’t yet “explained it away”. But I have enough reasons to believe that it would soon be.

(end of digression, should I say?)

I suppose the parallel is more than obvious. When we knew next to nothing about the water cycle, God was an excellent explanation for floods and droughts. Now we know far too much to make him responsible for any of that. Much like how the non-physical mind has been reserved for the absolutely mysterious (unexplained, not known to be unexplainable) none use God as an explanation for any phenomenon on this side of Big Bang today. Except for selfish reasons ofcourse [1].

As far as being technically right by calling oneself an agnostic goes… what exactly are you trying to say? Is your point that the existence of God cannot be disproved? Do you believe in the tooth fairy? Do you believe that Santa Claus exists? Do you believe in the flying spaghetti monster? What about the invisible pink unicorn? Or the teapot in orbit? [3][4]

Am sorry, I’d rather be technically incorrect and answer in the negative.

References:

1. http://masoia.blogspot.com/2007/08/god-of-small-things.html

2. http://masoia.blogspot.com/2007/07/down-rabbit-hole.html

3. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Falsifiability

4. http://www.ted.com/index.php/talks/view/id/113

Tuesday, December 11, 2007

Disturbed

This happened before the coffee shop painted itself red for Christmas. And before it replaced its brown cups with more festive looking ones that said “Pass the Cheer”.

The day had been rather uneventful. With the semester coming to an end, projects that would be started and finished on the day they were due were commonplace. It was one of those days. And I was punching keys on my computer over my Grande coffee.

I was sitting beside the large window at the far corner. The chair pretty much faced the wall. Outside, wind was blowing heavily and the campus was deserted. I was buried deep in the program that I was writing when I heard some people settle down at a table behind me.

Have you noticed how they say ‘The way I see it’ here. It was the voice of a professor. Or a PhD student I thought. Student of literature or some such thing. I don’t know. What I did know was that he was referring to what was written on the coffee cup. The coffee shop prints some words-of-wisdom of random people under the heading ‘The way I see it’.

Why do people have to play it so safe? Why can’t they just rather say ‘The way it IS?’ He didn’t sound irritated. But he wasn’t exactly at ease either.

Well… probably because they are just not sure that that’s the way it is. All that they know is that that’s the way they see it.

This had to be the professor’s grad student. Student of psychology… maybe?

The man was almost furious now. See? You are doing it too. Why should you say ‘probably’ when that’s what you believe?

Same reason Sir. I’m just not sure. And so I don’t believe it either. I’m just guessing.

Oh come on… you know it as well as I do. We can never be sure of anything. Everything’s a theory. Some just don’t look like it.

I have developed this new way of writing programs. It is called save-the-worst-for-the-last. It works well for me. I spend ninety percent of the time cornering the most difficult part of the program and then I go for the throat. I was in the first ninety percent when this was happening.

How is your thesis on risk coming along?

A third voice? Probably a different pair. This was a student certainly. And he was talking to one too. It is shaping up well. This had to be a PhD student.

It is shaping up quite well actually. I’m using some ideas from the course on Chaos and Randomness. Actually, I think I can explain it to you even if I cut out the math.

This is going to be interesting, I thought. Particularly now that I just had 4 hours left for the deadline to expire and I was nowhere close to completion.

The furious prof was saying…. You know how Feynman once said that we are only sure when we are wrong. Otherwise the most we can say is that we haven’t yet been proven wrong and have no idea if we would ever be.

Yes. But you are missing the point here. I think it is perfectly alright to say that you see something in a certain way. Like it does on the cup here. After all, generally a thing is far more complex than what is seen from different perspectives. And it only helps to know what someone else sees in something.

I was thinking of all my computer science friends to whom this would sound so abstract that they would run away.

Indeed, the prof said. But all this soft talk gives kids the impression that things are all amorphous. That nothing can be said about anything and that somehow making statements which are NOT clear enough is a sign of intellectual maturity.

In the meantime, I missed a part of the explanation of the thesis on Risk.

...the thing is, the student was saying, that it often happens that someone makes a decision that is not the one most likely to succeed. And by sheer chance he happens to succeed. This draws more attention than it ought to and the hasty lot concludes that that was the right thing to do. The symmetric case also is true. By sheer chance, a choice that was most likely to be right proves to be wrong and the same lot quickly concludes that it pays to be wrong.

But that’s not completely nonsensical, is it?

No. The trouble is with criticizing choices in retrospect. We just miss the point that the choice that proved to be wrong could indeed have been the most promising at the time that it was made. Chance is not something that humans have evolved to understand. And that is reason that we miss this point…

The other conversation had begun to smell more of consensus while I wasn’t paying attention. It had also broken free of the cup and leapt into the arena of philosophy of science.

… it is non-falsifiable theories that people are most comfortable with. Because, by definition, they do not have the fear of being proven wrong. Isn’t it ironic that the falsifiable theories, which are more than anything else, likely to model reality correctly, are also the ones that people trust the least?

I heard some shuffling of feet and soon came more voices. One of which said…You know what he says about ownership in The English Patient?

A student? A professor? Philosophy major? I wasn’t getting any better at guessing. But it was looking like I would finish my project on time after all.

Well… he says that he hates ownership the most but later he claims her…

“Sir”, someone called. A woman was standing before me. “We’d love to let you continue your work Sir. But we have to close early today.” “Oh. OK. But why is that?” “It looks like there’s going to be a storm tonight Sir. Also, you see, we have only had you this evening.”

Friday, August 10, 2007

God of small things

When in college, God popped up somehow in a conversation that I wasn’t paying much attention to and a friend of mine said to me, “It’s the kind of thing you like, the question of whether God exists”. She probably knew of the seemingly weird articles that I wrote for an email group then where asking the most important questions was the surest way to becoming uncool. But far from being the kind of thing that I was interested in, I hadn’t once considered spending time on God because my worldview (which I now know is called “naturalistic”) was nice and clean without one.

Lately though, I’ve been watching videos by freethinkers and have begun to notice how many believers I’m surrounded by. They come in all shapes, sizes and colours. I’ve talked with some of them. Some quite moderate. Others not quite so. And I noticed something remarkable. They strive to find a place for their God. They just need some place to put him. If you tell them about evolution, they will tell you that God set it all up. If you tell them about the Big Bang, they will tell you that God sparked it. Some put him in the skies, others in other dimensions beyond our reach, yet others in sub atomic particles which haven’t yet been probed, sometimes they make him the source of strange cosmic waves which are for some reason interested in your life, sometimes they put him in you, sometimes he’s out of space and time completely and sometimes (beat this) above all reason.

Ask me and I’d say this is quite an interesting phenomenon. Why would an otherwise-sane person of normal intelligence (in some cases, super normal) go to such lengths to protect her God? Why would an otherwise intellectually-honest person pretend to not see the unreasonableness? What is in it for them? Why screw their own brain? Why throw away one’s common sense? I think I know the answer.

In Richard Bach’s Illusion, when the Messiah is asked “Do you live in this world at all?” He says something that amounts to “No. Do you? All of us live in different worlds. You think you live in the same world as your tennis crazy neighbour? The Wimbledon started this week and you didn’t even hear about it. You think you live in his world? You think you live in my world?” You could say that Bach was playing with different connotations of the word world. The truth however, is that we don’t live in this Universe. Don’t get me wrong. We don’t live on a rock that revolves around a ball of burning gas. We live in cities or towns or villages where the sun rises in the morning and sets at night. We are not made up of atoms and molecules. We are made of skin and bone and muscles and sometimes you break a bone or tear a ligament. The laws of physics don’t determine anything. The professors at college decide the questions for the test. Your dad decides if your pocket money needs a raise and your boss decides what you work on. The laws of physics are not even important. Rarely do you throw a ball up. If you throw it harder it reaches higher. And whether you like it or not it falls back and not always as expected. We live in, what some people like to call, the Middle World. Neither the big world with balls of burning gas we call stars, nor the small world where electrons flirt with nuclei. We live, in the Middle World.

So much for the middle-ness in size. There’s a middle-ness in time too. You do not live in a world that’s been around for 4.5 billion years. You don’t live in a Universe that might collapse in or burst out. Your Universe started when you were born. And will end the day you die. If when you die, man has unanswered questions, they will remain unanswered for ever in your world. If you die in a battle, the battle never ended for you. There never was peace re-established. If you died before Christ, he was never in your world. If you died without hearing about a beautiful beach on the west coast of Africa, there was never such a thing.

Inasmuch as they would like to pretend otherwise, the God that the believers strive to find a place for is not a God of the gaps, it is not a God of ignorance, it is not a God who created the universe, it is not a God who planted life on earth, it is not even the God in the scriptures. It is the God who runs the Middle World.

Probably we will one day find out how energy can pop out of nowhere and create a universe. Probably we will shatter electrons till they give up. Probably String theory would be falsified. Probably not. Probably we will figure out a way to duplicate the brain. Probably the materialists were right all along. Probably not.

But matters in the Middle World are quite different. Not everything in the Middle World makes sense. And there is little reason to be optimistic about what we would do here. You run into old friends on the streets. Some meetings change your life. Some blunders shatter it. Little decisions estrange your loved ones. A bad job sometimes is the best thing that happens to you. You break your leg on the way to an interview. Your archrival gets the job. You end up in a better job and she goes bankrupt. Chaos rules. Things make sense in hindsight but while looking into the future, there’s just one thing you are sure of – that it is going to be nothing like you imagined – almost certainly.

It is an extremely attractive proposition to have someone run the Middle World. Especially if this person who runs it loves you no matter what. Sometimes the course of your life seems to depend on what you do. But largely, he makes sure it goes like it ought to. Things might not look very promising at times but of course, he runs the place. You’ve got the boss on your side. So chill.

Discussions about God generally involve things like the beginning of the Earth and the beginning of life. The truth however, is that I’m yet to meet a believer who can honestly say “I thought and thought about the beginning of the universe and I found God to be a satisfactory explanation.” Or “I didn’t believe the scriptures first but after lot of reasoning, I concluded they were right”. What is more likely is that you would hear something like “You know I wasn’t sure at first, but then last summer I really really wished that this would happen and it DID” or “Praying gives me peace of mind”. It is not the beginning of the world or the evolution of the eye that makes people believe in God. It is the chaos of the Middle World.

Whoever thinks that science will one day get rid of God simply doesn’t know his utility. We might figure it all out but we would still need someone to run our Middle world. Someone to salute before you start your car because you don’t know what could be around the corner. Science might bring the big God down. The one who sparked the big bang and planted life of earth. But the God of small things, the master of the Middle World will remain invincible.

Wednesday, July 04, 2007

Down the rabbit-hole

The notepad that you use on your computer to edit stuff is a good example of an editor. It is a program that allows you to write things on the computer. The letters that you type out are reflected on the computer screen and then saved as a file. An editor is a computer program like any other - a sequence of instructions written by a human programmer specifying what has to be done when the keys are pressed and how things have to be displayed and saved and the like. The point is that it is a computer program. What you see on the screen is what the program does. Programs, which I described as being sequences of instructions to the computer, are written by human programmers using editors. (So notepad was written using an editor)

I was on the way back after losing a racquetball match (least unusual) and walking beside the lake towards our lab. I do not know for certain if it were the ducks or the breeze that caused me to ask that particularly inappropriate question. How did they write the first editor program? I was in a light mood, you can see. Well… by pencil on paper I’d say, said my friend who’d won the match. And? How did it get on to the computer? I could hardly help asking. They must have scanned and OCRed it ofcourse he said. Being in an equally light mood helped. That was a wonderful answer. An OCR or an optical character recognizer is a horrendously complex program that recognizes written characters and makes it understandable to the computer. Wait a minute, I said. But how did they write the OCR program? Suppressing a laugh, he said, You shouldn’t ask such questions.

Thankfully, we were both kidding and it all ended in a hearty laugh. The specifics of the programs that came before notepad happened were not really important. It also didn’t matter that we did not know the real answer. What ever that might have been, it had to be something simpler than the OCR. Infact, punch cards were programmed by punching holes on cards. And you didn’t need already punched cards to do that. And there were a hundred other ways to input characters and record them. It didn’t really matter.

I went on a walk later that evening near the other side of the lake. Quite unusually, I saw a white rabbit with pink eyes. There was some weird deliberation in its ways. There was something about it that made me follow it. It might have sensed it. It ran soon towards the hole. I persisted. Surprisingly enough, the hole was quite big for the rabbit. Infact, big enough for me. And that was how I ended up in the rabbit hole.

I was only momentarily in the dark. Before I knew it, I was falling into what I thought was a bottomless pit before my bottom hit the bottom of the pit. I miraculously survived. Probably to meet a man who was at this coffee table. Before my lips could part, he said with a gentle smile- I’ve been waiting for you. I embarrassingly got up brushing off some hay that I had fallen on.

Without saying a word, he pushed a thick book towards me. It all was rather spooky and I didn’t think this was a place where you asked questions. He looked at me, and then at the book, as if asking me to read it. I opened it. It looked like a normal book. Except that for a book of its size, it started rather abruptly. In the beginning, the OCR was used to write the editor, I read softly, as if proving to him that I indeed was interested. I looked up. And he motioned me to carry on. Rabbit-hole or not, I don’t continue when I don’t understand. I said, it doesn’t make sense. Why not? he asked, not bothered in the least. I wanted to say isn’t it obvious, you moron.

Rather I said An OCR, is a program too, right? He agreed. How did they write it without an editor then? I asked, without sounding arrogant.

He sighed as if saying not another moron. He started: You see, a program is only made of 1s and 0s. I nodded. An OCR is a special sequence of 1s and zeros. It was there in the RAM (that’s computer’s memory, for the uninitiated) all the time.

But, I interrupted, how could it have got there in the first place?

He continued, not bothered at all, You see, it HAD to be there and it was. This book doesn’t talk of when it was not there. Obviously, it was always there.

It was my turn to explain now. Dear friend, you see computers did not always have keyboards. They did not always look like they do now and they did not always need an editor to program.

He jumped at the last line - You see you said it yourself. They did not always need an editor to program. So they would have written an OCR without an editor.

I counted to 10 and then started. An OCR, my friend is a program that is a thousand times more complicated than an editor. It is more likely that they would use an editor to write an OCR program rather than use an OCR to scan in an editor program. Infact, we have no OCRs good enough for the job now.

He jumped at the last line again. There, my friend, that is where you are missing the point. If there were not OCRs, how did they write the first editor program? Moreover, this book says it.

I wasn’t sure what he was made of. I thought he was a moron then. But I wasn’t expecting to lose an argument to a moron. I did lose though.

I started afresh: Computers did not always look like this. These things with keyboards and all are pretty recent.

He interrupted, You are wrong again my friend, this book says that the first computer was an Apple Machintosh and it came with an editor and more.

But Sir, I said almost dramatically, I know for a fact that that’s untrue. We have pictures and books about older computers. Infact we still have many around, though people don’t use them anymore.

And have you seen any of them?

Well sir, I’m afraid I haven’t. But Sir, it certainly could not have been the OCR…

He interrupted. Tell me, aren’t computers prone to stray magnetic noise?

Yes Sir. If they are of sufficiently high intensity, they can even flip some bits.

Exactly, my friend. So you see, it is not impossible for the OCR program to have existed in the RAM.

And how is that Sir?

Some magnetic noise might have switched the bits in the RAM exactly to create an OCR program.

But Sir, that’s extremely unlikely. In fact Sir, that is almost impossible.

I like that word son, he said, triumphantly. The word “almost” I mean. That means that you cannot say for sure that that did not happen, right?

No Sir, I cannot.

So it is perfectly plausible that the OCR program was created without using an editor. And that an OCR was indeed used to write the first editor, as this book says?

Yes Sir, it is not impossible.

And you have personally not seen any of these old computers without keyboards, have you?

No Sir, I haven’t.

I don’t know if it was triumph I saw or relief in his eyes as he left with his book.

I walked back to where I’d fallen and looked up the hole. This place was too far below. And I missed the lake and the ducks and the breeze.

Saturday, June 09, 2007

Some holiday

Blame this on the statistical machine translation project. Or on me, if you like. Depending on how much you like to treat man as being an instrument of the world. Pardon the mood. Blame it on the book I’ve been reading – Sophie’s World. Or on me, if you like, like I said before.

Correlations are what I’ve been pondering about for a few days now. Unlike a lot of boring mathematics, this is easy to understand. Guess it is best summed up by the story of the old woman who thought that the sun rose because her hen cried. She is not to blame. (At least not more than ultra modern women who play lines like ‘He is a typical Piscean’ and ‘That’s not surprising. She’s cancerean’). Not many steer clear of the correlation-causation fallacy. If two things consistently happen together, you conclude that the one that precedes causes the one that follows. Sounds logical. Evolutionary psychologists would say that it is not you but mindless evolution that is to blame for the fallacy. We’ll come to that, probably.

This is not so much about the correlation-causation fallacy as it is about spurious correlations. In situations where guessing is all that is possible, it might not be a sin, after all, to conclude causation from correlation. (As, is the case in our project, the details of which I decided the reader deserves not to be subjected to).

Events which indeed are related would appear to be correlated. Not surprisingly. But when only finite number of observations are made, there is a good chance of observing correlations among unrelated variables (Can’t help quoting the ‘Typical of a Piscean’ line). In fact, you are more likely than not to make such an observation. The chance of making such observations only reduces as you make more and more observations. Inasmuch as I would like to avoid words of wisdom, Truth prevails over time and spurious correlations die out and only the true ones remain when a large number of observations are made. The trouble, however, is that you might need to make a conclusion even when you have not made enough observations (seen enough of life) and like I said, a couple of spurious correlations will make their way into your system.

Now, spurious correlations would certainly explain some odd coincidences that occurred recently. And if they don’t suffice, we’ll call upon the the-idol-was-in-the-stone argument. The latter, if you are not familiar concerns the sculptor who, upon being asked about his creation said that all he did was to merely expose the idol in the stone. How would you counter that? You can see anything you want in a stone. Well… almost anything. Like in your observations.

Well….well… for starters, I was reading the chapter on Karl Marx and the exploitation of the proletariat while my Grandmom was telling me about a small family here. The woman works part-time in a teashop for Rs. 50 (a dollar and a quarter) a day and the man chops firewood for a living. I must have got to the proletariat revolution part when she said that we’d have to sell off some of our land because we weren’t using it and the government wanted them to be owned by people who could grow something there.

I wasn’t paying much attention to what the neighbour was telling my Grandmom. I was reading about this dangerous idea of Darwin. Simple, small but consistent processes over time can create a world so wonderful that man had to create God to explain it. (Time and pressure, that’s all it takes - Andy, Shawshank Redemption) Thanks to the cocktail-party effect, it was when I was reading about the uniqueness of individuals and ‘random errors’ in cell division (something central to Darwin’s idea) that I paid attention to the discussion going on in the background. It was her two kids that she was talking about. One of the boys studied really well and was on his way to win some kind of a scholarship and the other one had trouble retaining what was taught to him.

After a good dose of Darwin and genes and genealogies I decided I needed a walk. It was really hot and so I wore a mundu (a variant of dhoti, not worn like one though). When I asked my Grandmom if I was wearing it the right way, she said ‘Oh….just like your grandfather used to’.

The next chapter was on Freud. Natural instincts suppressed and locked up in the basement to conform to unwritten rules, the constant tension between desire and guilt…. I could not agree more. Buses here are pretty fast and certainly not the best place to read a thing. But I discovered that a particular position of the bag on my lap and my elbow on my bag absorbed enough shock to limit the vibrations of the book just enough to let me read. The window helped. I could look out. I saw two nuns standing by the road.

I was glad Gaarder shared my views about new age worthless philosophy that I’ve come so much to abhor… not least because of the pseudo-scientific theories I’ve seen people on orkut proposing. And the examples of nonsense books that he provides… are perfect: Life After Death? The Secrets of Spiritism, Tarot, The UFO Phenomenon, Healing, The Return of Gods, You have been here before, What is Astrology? That was almost exactly when my uncle showed me a photo album. They were photos taken during a jathakam kodukkal ceremony. That’s the ritual performed where a book (traditionally a bunch of dry leafs with markings) which predicts all major events in one’s life exchanges hands. And if you lived in this part of the world, you better make sure these things are done like they ought to be done. You never know what the gods might resort to if they are displeased. Gaarder drives the nail home with one line while talking about the list of books he mentions and the kinds of ideas they represent: “The difference between real philosophy and these books is more or less the same as the difference between real love and pornography.”`

Saturday, April 21, 2007

Room for cream

The queue is unusually long. Generally there are not more than 5 people. And now there are more than 8. I am never here at this time. It is nearly 9:00.

Meantime, just a few thousand kilometres away, on a nondescript street in the suburbs of an otherwise buzzing city, Shivanna expertly manoeuvres his bicycle around the stones piled up by boys who had to quit their game of cricket last night because the neighbourhood doctor made a fuss again. Leaning on the compound wall, Shivanna called out ‘Aallu…’ as the little boy came out to the gate running as usual clutching 15 rupees and wearing his navy blue school uniform trousers and a clean white vest.

There was probably one less person at the counter because the queue was moving rather slowly.

Not very far from Shivanna’s street, Mr Pandey settled down with the morning newspaper and a cup of coffee that he had managed to fix for himself. The milk had boiled over as he had gone to answer the telephone call. It wouldn’t have been as bad if it hadn’t been a wrong number. And if Sivaram hadn’t been at the door soon after to borrow the spark plug cleaner again. Why didn’t he just buy another scooter if his failed to start every morning? Or a modest spark plug cleaner at least. He could’ve used more milk in his coffee.

Who ever had designed this place was a fox. He placed the pastry showcase along the length of the queue. I’m not hungry. I just need some coffee. Let’s see… 3 more people between me and the counter.

A little more than 8 hrs by train from Mr Pandey’s city, Bijumon ran barefoot on the tarred road. He wouldn’t dare try that at mid day. Madhavettan flashed a broad smile and he returned a grin. Biju wouldn’t stop today to chat with his son like he had done the previous day. The milk van had come and collected all the milk before he could reach. Today, he didn’t have to try hard to read the board that hung near the closed milk booth. ‘Thozhilaali samaram’ – one of the few things he could read - ‘Worker’s strike’. As he headed back home, he suddenly realized that he didn’t have to have his regular glass of milk. He ran up to Madhavettan’s house to chat with his buddy.

Can I help who's next? The cute one asked.
Yes. Could I have a tall coffee?
Do you need some room for cream?
Yes please.

Thursday, April 05, 2007

I don't hate no double negation

I didn’t get no sleep last night. And I haven’t got no time today. My head ain’t no good for work now. And I haven’t got nothing useful to do until my class which ain’t starting not in another 2 hours. The talk I tried listening to now was not dislikable for the rest but for someone who needs as much sleep as I do it wasn’t no likeable. So out of the blue I think not from nowhere dawned upon me this idea of sitting in this coffee shop and writing about double negations. And it ain’t no bad idea coz the caffeine, the hazelnut, the people, the music and Microsoft’s colourful wrigglys are keeping me from not sleeping. Some are red and the one’s that aren’t no red are green. And I don’t see no blue ones. I checked up wiki on the use of ain’t. And wiki said it ain’t no good. But for something on double negations, I don’t think there’s nothing as good as ain’t. For if it ain’t for ain’t double negations would not be no good.

It isn’t the least disinteresting how with all the false statements you still don’t find it impossible to read. There must be some sentences here that aren’t no syntactically wrong and even lesser that aren’t plain nonsense. But a bag of nonsense can make so much sense. A bag of nonsense can assert that a bag of nonsense is no nonsense. Guess I don’t hate no double negation. Not never.

Sunday, July 02, 2006

Perfect Sense

Little teddy loved school
Ofcourse he wasn't a fool
Little teddy loved Ms Fletcher
his lovely science teacher
With pair of eyes dark brown
and countenance that never did frown
she always made perfect sense
on either side of the fence
"Why", he asked her one day
a sunny day in may
did the earth go retrograde
every three revolutions it made
and why did the sun rise in the west
during all months but august?
a broad smile gave she
and her eyes glowed in glee
as she explained the law of gravitation
with great admiration
for the man who made it
Michael Forsyth
Ms Fletcher had once again
with absolutely no pain
made perfect sense
as she would every time thence.



(Written over breakfast sometime in March/April 2005)

Sunday, May 14, 2006

Bewitched

I have wished quite often that I was the old kind of engineer. The kind who built machines, houses, bridges, furnaces, cars and clocks. The kind who uses pencils, sharpeners and A3 sized papers. The kind who had to roll up his sleeves, put on helmets or wear high boots to watch his designs materialize. The kind of engineer that I am generally sits at his desk cluttered with wires and phones and unwashed coffee mugs and punches keys. At the end of the day, sleeves remain unsoiled, papers unused, pencils untouched and the clutter unmoved. The world hardly changes. No floors added to a skyscraper. No pillars erected. No metal melted. Nothing moulded. Nothing shaped.

It is only to please the crowd, ofcourse, that inspite of drawing up designs, building, watching my machines work, watching them march in step to my command that I wish to abandon them in favor of their worldly counterparts. For, in all earnest, a server crunching numbers, a mind numbing number of them, accurate to a bit, while being relocated a million times a second is no lesser a marvel of technology than is an airborne 747. But, like the cursed invincible Greek hero, it doesn’t stand a chance against the flying machine. For unlike the flying machine that swaggers in the open skies while jaws drop, the server works its magic silently tucked away in a metal box sitting snugly in an aircooled basement. Pathetically unromantic.

But…

At times, when the madness hits the roof, when the sound of the metal and the numbing beckoning of the soiled sleeves in my head drown the sound of the keystrokes, it is the thought of the conundrums that nails me down. For inspite of the curse of unromanticism, the conundrums are the reason the heroes flourish. Albeit cursed. Like the zombies serving the mighty hermits the engineers of my kind are bewitched by the conundrums. I would not trade them for soiled sleeves. For watching my ships stand the storm. For watching jaws drop while my machines fly. For nothing.

For I believe, and with good reason, that no cheering of crowds shall match the magic of the conundrums.

They come packaged as little truths that defy reason. And you stare at them in disbelief as the voice in your head says Thy shall not disbelieve. Thy shall not doubt the power of reason. And at that moment you ask yourself There is no spoon? Ofcourse there is. It is right there. You can see your face in it, mercilessly skewed. And for once you know - it’s rightly deserved. You make some observations - read some logs, verify some numbers and check some statuses. And voila!!...there you have a perfect conundrum - some observations that imply the impossible – the logical inconsistency of the underlying system. Anything that implies something impossible is false. You know that. You believe that. You better do or the wrath of the gods of pure reason shall reduce your world to ashes. The world of truths and proofs and implications and beliefs. But what do you trust more? The spoon in your hand or the voice in your head? You have been there before. Right there. Holding the same spoon and hearing the same voice. The voice has always been right. You remind yourself of that. But the spoon. I can see it. I can feel it. I can read the log. I can query the database. I see the output. I can validate the result. It is true. I am staring at the impossible. My Gods are defied. My world burns…

And then yet again… the voice triumphs. I know the conundrum was an illusion. There was no spoon indeed. The Gods have been appeased. My world is far too powerful for the illusions. For the conundrums. My Gods shall protect me and my world. Always. My world shall stand the test of illusions. The test of conundrums. The test of misread logs and mistaken measurements….

I rise at the end of a day’s work. The coffee rings on my desk need cleaning. The wires need some sorting and the phone needs some rest. I smirk at my own blindness. At my own madness. But I need no crowds to cheer. I need no jaws to drop. For in a day’s work, I saw my world burn. I saw it fall. And then I saw it rise from the ashes. I saw the spoon. I saw it turn into thin air. I would be back here again. I shall see the spoon again and I shall see it vanish. For no soiled sleeves would I trade the conundrums.